Errors, near errors, and interrupted errors. This helped the author to develop a list of concepts common in compassion- attentiveness, listening, confronting, involvement, helping, presence and understanding.
They were operationally defined through measurement using logbooks pre intervention, 4 weeks post intervention, and 12 weeks post intervention periods. I have chosen the above article to critique because of the wide media interest and the public perception of nurses failing to meet the basic need of patients, especially elderly and vulnerable patients BBC, Sleep quality was conceptually defined as a subjective response to persistently interrupted or uninterrupted sleep with or without difficulty falling asleep.
In my opinion, there are two main problems with this. Sample Inclusion and Exclusion Criteria The participants are acute care hospital nurses with fatigue at work. This is a secondary reference, not a primary source, and should therefore be used with caution. It is not made clear if the patients were in the presence of professionals when signing the letter of informed consent-if they were then the criticism of coercion could be levelled.
The participants were readily available at either their home or hospital to enter logbook data.
It is important for the author to examine their own role in the collection of data and in how the research questions were formulated. Drowsy driving and MVC were operationally defined through measurement by logbooks during the initial data collection, 4 weeks post intervention, and 12 weeks post intervention.
The major study concepts include: The author describes why these particular people were chosen for the study but not how. I can understand why the author used this approach- after all, a split has developed with the two founders of grounded theory Glasser and Strauss over the use of the coding paradigm e.
Hospital staff nurses from medical-surgical units at three Michigan hospitals were selected for the study without regard for age, race, gender, or shift worked.
Sampling and Setting The nurses were obtained through a mailing list for three Michigan acute care hospitals. Drowsy driving was not conceptually defined; however, a possible conceptual definition is serious cognitive-behavioral action that results from driving while sleepy due to sleep deprivation, shift work, or untreated sleep conditions.
The author uses key phrases used by the interviewees to complement each concept that emerged. Research into this field could produce valuable results to enhance existing knowledge and understanding; however because of the flaws in research and the potential for bias the results produced here cannot be used.
The research concludes that compassion is of value to nurse and patient as it motivates both in forming a partnership to achieve the best outcome of care. Drowsy driving and motor vehicle crashes.
Ethics in research is of prime importance. No mention is made of how the research was explained to the patients or how the patients may have handled the effects of the study.
Artinian and Giske state that although this approach allows the author to build upon the work of previous research, if the variables of the research were obtained from the literature review then they may be wrong.
Theoretical Framework In Scott et al. The purposes of the study were to evaluate the effectiveness of FCMPN in improving sleep quality, reducing work-time drowsiness, and decreasing the potential for nurse injury and patient care errors.How to Critically Appraise an Article.
Jane M Young; Michael J Solomon Critical appraisal is a systematic process used to identify the strengths and weaknesses of a research article in order.
Critical Appraisal. In a study by Scott, Hofmeister, Rogness, & Rogers () it was noted that other industries have recognized the impact of shift work. Essay examples examples of critical appraisal essays in nursing for college.
Free sample essays Recently added sample essays: Critical appraisal th grade science essays essay martin luther king jr i have a dream speech essay.
Critical Appraisal of Qualitative Research Study Problem Statement The problem addressed in this study is reported in the work of Carusone, Loeb, and Lohfield () entitled "Pneumonia Care and the Nursing Home: A Qualitative Descriptive Study of Resident and Family Member Perspectives".
Critical Appraisal Essay (Caress et al, Critical Appraisal Indiana Nursing Student Writing (Term Paper Sample) Nursing Critical Appraisal (Ghergherechi et al., ) The Purpose of this non- randomized study is to establish the prevalence of vitamin D deficiency and secondary hyperparathyroidism in obese children.
The imposition of prevailing and treating charges which. According to Al-Qazaz et al (), the PICOT was presented by the researcher in the study were, P: Type 2diabetes Show More A critical appraisal of two articles using the appropriate CASP guidelines.Download